DWDaniel WallerEngineering. Leadership. Stories.
All Factory Floor stories

Lessons from the Factory Floor / 13

I Didn’t Know How to Fix It

One of our largest milling machines suddenly developed a fault with its magnetic clamping system.

The magnets wouldn't switch correctly.

Sometimes only a few would energise.

Other times they'd switch, but with nowhere near enough holding force.

The machine was effectively useless.

There was another problem.

I'd never worked on an industrial magnetic clamping system before.

And I was the only electrically qualified engineer on site.

No one to hand it over to.

No one internally with the answer.

So I started fault-finding.

Hours later, I'd reached that point most engineers will recognise...

I'd looked at it for so long that nothing made sense anymore.

Then I discovered the original manufacturer of the magnetic system had gone out of business.

No technical support.

No service engineer.

No easy answer.

So I stopped looking for someone who knew our machine and started looking for someone who understood the technology behind it.

Eventually I found a company specialising in high-power battery systems.

Different industry.

Same principles.

I called them, explained the symptoms and sent over some photographs.

Within minutes they pointed me towards something I hadn't considered.

A DC solid-state relay.

Suddenly, everything made sense.

There was still one problem.

Nobody I contacted could supply and replace a relay of that size.

So we sourced one ourselves for next-day delivery.

The following day we installed it.

Magnets switched correctly.

Holding force returned.

Machine back in production.

Two days downtime.

That breakdown taught me something far more valuable than how a magnetic clamping system works.

You don't need to know everything to solve difficult problems.

You need to know when you've reached the limit of your own knowledge.

Then be curious enough to look somewhere else.

Different industries solve similar engineering problems every day.

Pride can keep you staring at the same problem for hours.

Curiosity makes you pick up the phone.

Great engineers don't always have the answer.

They know how to find it.

Have you ever solved an engineering problem by asking someone completely outside your own field?